Follow Along: Testing 3 Pop Traffic Sources with a Gift Card Offer – Let’s See Who Wins

btaliat

Active member
Joined
Jun 3, 2025
Messages
2,942
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Hey everyone,


I’ve decided to start this follow along to document my latest campaign test and share the results as they come in. I’ll be launching this campaign on Sunday, and I want to keep things transparent from the start so others can learn from my approach — and maybe you can point out what I might be missing before I burn through my budget.


Campaign Details


  • Offer Type: Gift Card (incentive-based)
  • Payout: $2.00
  • Target Country: Australia
  • Traffic Sources: Propeller Ads, PopCash, and PopAds
  • Landing Pages: 4 variations to test engagement and CTR
  • Daily Budget: $10
  • Targeted Daily Revenue: $15
  • Tracking Platform: Thrive Tracker
  • Initial Budget per Traffic Network: $100

Strategy


My plan is to split the initial budget evenly across the three traffic networks and monitor performance closely. Each network will start with the same setup — the same offer, the same landers, and the same targeting — so that I can compare them on a level playing field.


The goal is to figure out which source gives me the best balance of conversions and cost per click. Once I identify a winner, I’ll funnel more budget into that network and scale it up.


If a traffic source shows no conversions or has very low click numbers after initial testing, I won’t hesitate to cut it off. The idea is to avoid wasting money and to focus on the channel that shows the most promise.


Why These Traffic Sources?


I chose Propeller Ads, PopCash, and PopAds because they’re affordable, have high volume in the GEO I’m targeting, and are relatively easy to set up. While they’re not always known for the highest-quality traffic, they can still produce results with the right offer and targeting — especially in incentive niches like gift cards.


The Role of Landing Pages


Instead of direct linking, I’ll be using four different landing pages to pre-sell the offer and encourage clicks. These will vary in design, copy, and CTA placement to see which style resonates best with Australian users. My hope is that at least one of these landers will stand out and give me a strong CTR boost.


Expectations


Given the payout of $2.00 and my daily revenue target of $15, I’m looking at about 8 conversions per day to hit my goal. It’s modest, but it’s a realistic starting point for testing. Once I find a working combination, I can scale to higher budgets and potentially aim for $50/day or more.


Next Steps Before Launch


  1. Final review of the 4 landing pages to ensure fast load times.
  2. Double-check tracking setup in Thrive.
  3. Set up identical campaigns across the three networks for a fair test.
  4. Prepare to monitor stats daily and cut underperformers quickly.

I’ll update this thread regularly with performance stats, adjustments, and lessons learned — whether I hit my target or crash and burn.


If you’ve run similar pop traffic campaigns for gift card offers, I’d love to hear your thoughts on what worked for you — especially in terms of GEO targeting or lander style.


Here’s to finding a winner among the three!
 
  • We value your privacy

    We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.

    See further information and configure your preferences

    These cookies are required to enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may not reject these.
    We deliver enhanced functionality for your browsing experience by setting these cookies. If you reject them, enhanced functionality will be unavailable.
    Cookies set by third parties may be required to power functionality in conjunction with various service providers for security, analytics, performance or advertising purposes.
Top